Foss V Harbottle Essaytyper

The Victoria Park Company is an incorporated body, and the conduct with which the Defendants are charged in this suit is an injury not to the Plaintiffs exclusively; it is an injury to the whole corporation by individuals whom the corporation entrusted with powers to be exercised only for the good of the corporation. And from the case of The Attorney-General v Wilson (1840) Cr & Ph 1 (without going further) it may be stated as undoubted law that a bill or information by a corporation will lie to be relieved in respect of injuries which the corporation has suffered at the hands of persons standing in the situation of the directors upon this record. This bill, however, differs from that in The Attorney-General v Wilson in this—that, instead of the corporation being formally represented as Plaintiffs, the bill in this case is brought by two individual corporators, professedly on behalf of themselves and all the other members of the corporation, except those who committed the injuries complained of—the Plaintiffs assuming to themselves the right and power in that manner to sue on behalf of and represent the corporation itself.

It was not, nor could it successfully be, argued that it was a matter of course for any individual members of a corporation thus to assume to themselves the right of suing in the name of the corporation. In law the corporation and the aggregate members of the corporation are not the same thing for purposes like this; and the only question can be whether the facts alleged in this case justify a departure from the rule which, primâ facie , would require that the corporation should sue in its own name and in its corporate character, or in the name of someone whom the law has appointed to be its representative...

The first objection taken in the argument for the Defendants was that the individual members of the corporation cannot in any case sue in the form in which this bill is framed. During the argument I intimated an opinion, to which, upon further consideration, I fully adhere, that the rule was much too broadly stated on the part of the Defendants. I think there are cases in which a suit might properly be so framed. Corporations like this, of a private nature, are in truth little more than private partnerships; and in cases which may easily be suggested it would be too much to hold that a society of private persons associated together in undertakings, which, though certainly beneficial to the public, are nevertheless matters of private property, are to be deprived of their civil rights, inter se , because, in order to make their common objects more attainable, the Crown or the Legislature may have conferred upon them the benefit of a corporate character. If a case should arise of injury to a corporation by some of its members, for which no adequate remedy remained, except that of a suit by individual corporators in their private characters, and asking in such character the protection of those rights to which in their corporate character they were entitled, I cannot but think that the principle so forcibly laid down by Lord Cottenham in Wallworth v Holt (4 Myl & Cr 635; see also 17 Ves 320, per Lord Eldon) and other cases would apply, and the claims of justice would be found superior to any difficulties arising out of technical rules respecting the mode in which corporations are required to sue.

But, on the other hand, it must not be without reasons of a very urgent character that established rules of law and practice are to be departed from, rules which, though in a sense technical, are founded on general principles of justice and convenience; and the question is whether a case is stated in this bill entitling the Plaintiffs to sue in their private characters...

Now, that my opinion upon this case may be clearly understood, I will consider separately the two principal grounds of complaint to which I have adverted, with reference to a very marked distinction between them. The first ground of complaint is one which, though it might primâ facie entitle the corporation to rescind the transactions complained of, does not absolutely and of necessity fall under the description of a void transaction. The corporation might elect to adopt those transactions, and hold the directors bound by them. In other words, the transactions admit of confirmation at the option of the corporation. The second ground of complaint may stand in a different position; I allude to the mortgaging in a manner not authorized by the powers of the Act. This, being beyond the powers of the corporation, may admit of no confirmation whilst any one dissenting voice is raised against it. This distinction is found in the case of Preston v The Grand Collier Dock Company (1840) 11 Sim 327, SC; 2 Railway Cases 335.

On the first point it is only necessary to refer to the clauses of the Act to shew that, whilst the supreme governing body, the proprietors at a special general meeting assembled, retain the power of exercising the functions conferred upon them by the Act of Incorporation, it cannot be competent to individual corporators to sue in the manner proposed by the Plaintiffs on the present record. This in effect purports to be a suit by cestui que trusts complaining of a fraud committed or alleged to have been committed by persons in a fiduciary character. The complaint is that those trustees have sold lands to themselves, ostensibly for the benefit of the cestui que trusts. The proposition I have advanced is that, although the Act should prove to be voidable, the cestui que trusts may elect to confirm it. Now, who are the cestui que trusts in this case? The corporation, in a sense, is undoubtedly the cestui que trust; but the majority of the proprietors at a special general meeting assembled, independently of any general rules of law upon the subject, by the very terms of the incorporation in the present case, has power to bind the whole body, and every individual corporator must be taken to have come into the corporation upon the terms of being liable to be so bound. How then can this Court act in a suit constituted as this is, if it is to be assumed, for the purposes of the argument, that the powers of the body of the proprietors are still in existence, and may lawfully be exercised for a purpose like that I have suggested? Whilst the Court may be declaring the acts complained of to be void at the suit of the present Plaintiffs, who in fact may be the only proprietors who disapprove of them, the governing body of proprietors may defeat the decree by lawfully resolving upon the confirmation of the very acts which are the subject of the suit. The very fact that the governing body of proprietors assembled at the special general meeting may so bind even a reluctant minority is decisive to shew that the frame of this suit cannot be sustained whilst that body retains its functions...


The second point which relates to the charges and incumbrances alleged to have been illegally made on the property of the company is open to the reasoning which I have applied to the first point, upon the question whether, in the present case, individual members are at liberty to complain in the form adopted by this bill; for why should this anomalous form of suit be resorted to, if the powers of the corporation may be called into exercise? But this part of the case is of greater difficulty upon the merits. I follow, with entire assent, the opinion expressed by the Vice-Chancellor in Preston v The Grand Collier Dock Company, that if a transaction be void, and not merely voidable, the corporation cannot confirm it, so as to bind a dissenting minority of its members. But that will not dispose of this question. The case made with regard to these mortgages or incumbrances is, that they were executed in violation of the provisions of the Act. The mortgagees are not Defendants to the bill, nor does the bill seek to avoid the security itself, if it could be avoided, on which I give no opinion. The bill prays inquiries with a view to proceedings being taken aliunde to set aside these transactions against the mortgagees. The object of this bill against the Defendants is to make them individually and personally responsible to the extent of the injury alleged to have been received by the corporation from the making of the mortgages. Whatever the case might be, if the object of the suit was to rescind these transactions, and the allegations in the bill shewed that justice could not be done to the shareholders without allowing two to sue on behalf of themselves and others, very different considerations arise in a case like the present, in which the consequences only of the alleged illegal Acts are sought to be visited personally upon the directors. The money forming the consideration for the mortgages was received, and was expended in, or partly in, the transactions which are the subject of the first ground of complaint. Upon this, one question appears to me to be, whether the company could confirm the former transactions, take the benefit of the money that has been raised, and yet, as against the directors personally, complain of the acts which they have done, by means whereof the company obtains that benefit which I suppose to have been admitted and adopted by such confirmation. I think it would not be open to the company to do this; and my opinion already expressed on the first point is that the transactions which constitute the first ground of complaint may possibly be beneficial to the company, and may be so regarded by the proprietors, and admit of confirmation. I am of opinion that this question—the question of confirmation or avoidance—cannot properly be litigated upon this record, regard being had to the existing state and powers of the corporation, and that therefore that part of the bill which seeks to visit the directors personally with the consequences of the impeached mortgages and charges, the benefit of which the company enjoys, is in the same predicament as that which relates to the other subjects of complaint. Both questions stand on the same ground, and, for the reasons which I stated in considering the former point, these demurrers must be allowed.

Do you need help with with essay, research paper, homework or even dissertation?

Visit our website – (

=================>>>CLICK HERE<<<=================

=================>>>CLICK HERE<<<=================

=================>>>CLICK HERE<<<=================

=================>>>GET ASSIGNMENT HELP<<<=================

=================>>>GET ASSIGNMENT HELP<<<=================

=================>>>GET ASSIGNMENT HELP<<<=================

sonnet 130 essays

technology in our lives essay writing

essay on durga puja in hindi for class 3

common good bowdoin essaytyper

uc application personal statement 2013

use of disguise in twelfth night essay

essay writing topics tagalog

smart words to use in an english essay

rka 141 summer assignment 2011 chevrolet

berkeley law opportunity scholarship essay format

critical thinking and problem solving rubric 4th

online learning essay conclusion graphic organizer

pro affirmative action essays

salwan public school afternoon holiday homework 2012 honda

essays on importance of mass media

oxford university geography personal statement

interesting hooks for essays

mba scholarship application essay sample

xtranormal persuasive essay

how to write essays for english literature

concentrated poverty essay questions

william t vollmann bibliography format

free term papers on women of ancient egypt

college admission appeal essay

our town research paper

differences between christianity and judaism essays on poverty

canterbury tales the cook essay help

essay on roy lichtenstein mural at equitable building new york

heinrich von kleist essay topics

dissertation proposal innovation meaning

examples of first person point of view essay

biogenesis baseball scandal essay

what it takes to be a real hero essay prompt

sample title of action research paper

sensorial education essay outline

jason mittell genre theory essay

mikrofiche dissertation help

letter of intent for scholarship examples essays

editorial opinion essay sample

jamie kilstein male privilege essay

how to write a good opening sentence for an essay

cover letter examples for resumes 2015

pere goriot essays on love

isolationism vs interventionism essay writer

gcse essay examples english

college application essay tutoring

mass media essay with outline

research paper on it pdf stephen

year 7 science homework cells worksheet

writing essays in french

best american essays of 2013

wake forest essay prompts 2014

eso 12 solved assignment 2013 toyota

curley’s wife dream essay

classification essay jobs

cover letter for teaching position in college sample

swami vivekananda english essay

chopin polonaise fantaisie analysis essay

how Hire Someone to Write My Research Paper write a 5 year plan essay

canadian style resume and cover letter

inlay wax classification essay

css past papers 2012 essay topics

list comparative words essays on love

outline for a sociology research paper apa

junior research paper interview questions

putrajaya perdana berhad scholarship essays

is sport good for us essay

gcse art coursework topics

free essays on french revolution

essay writing in english grammar

coherence in space order essay

swimlane diagramm beispiel essay

strong transitions in Hire Someone to Write My Research Paper essays

cover letter for hr executive jobs

roster staff assignment tool

axe apollo case study

designer babies debate essay template

resident evil outbreak all good endings for essays

good titles for essays about evil eyes

essay format types for sd

cerra scholarship essays

english time lesson 5 homework

ay springs to catch woodcocks analysis essay

cover letter examples geophysics institute

bp case study interview

community development cover letter

manifesto essay ideas

prose analysis essay prompts for the outsiders

mohanty feminism without borders essay contest

cultural differences ielts essay topics

research paper proposal first person

30 mile fire case study powerpoint

essay analytical writing

revolutionary terrorism essay question

graduate goals essay

junk food essay in short

Hire Someone to Write My Research Paper context essay ideas for imagination

homework is beneficial and should not be banned

kuvempu university distance education assignments 2014

assignment limitation code Hire Someone to Write My Research Paper off tempo

short cause and effect essay sample

research paper bulletin board ideas

styles of writing dissertation acknowledgements

discuss Hire Someone to Write My Research Paper an essay topic

cyclone ii ep2c35f672c6 pin assignments

persian gulf war thesis statement

bibliography difference between references and works

st johns county clerk of court criminal research paper

stop police brutality essay

fst1 assignment 2014 world

sure god does exist essay

admissions essay sample graduate

no dissertation doctorate

criminal Hire Someone to Write My Research Paper justice cover letters examples

the changeling robin jenkins/ critical essay

be honest with yourself essay

vora and company case study analysis in education

how long did it take you to write your college essay

free essays on hard work is the key to success

research papers to buy online

steve jobs vs bill gates compare and contrast essay

free a level essays

mit mites application essays

i graded your homework it was delicious too

operations management case study scribd books

cs61a homework solutions

cause and effect steroids essays

why write a thesis statement

lvalue required as left operand of assignment error coins

foss v harbottle essay format

the case study of a hmong community takes place in spanish

gun ownership persuasive essays

poetry submission cover letter

reconstruction of the south after the civil war essay

nz film industry essay typer

classic essays multiple choice questions

sara bledel bibliography generator

usable security research paper

ms 04 solved assignment 2015 best

madisonian model essay for pmr

my plate assignments

past experiences essay

salutation for cover letters when the recipient is unknown out on dvd

which of the following would be used in the body of a formal essay

$10 000 scholarship essay contest

allah islam photo essays

matthias grunewald crucifixion analysis essay

2000 word essay on responsibility of a citizen

best research paper topics sports news

all the world is a stage essay format

0 Replies to “Foss V Harbottle Essaytyper”

Lascia un Commento

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *